Family Files Wrongful Death Lawsuit Against NYC and DOT After Fatal Wrong-Way Crash

a pedestrian crosswalk at a dense urban intersection flanked by classic brick city buildings and metal traffic poles, with a blurred dark SUV driving past, natu

AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.

  • calendar_today November 19, 2026

Background: Fatal Wrong-Way Crash in Manhattan

The family of Valerie Schoeck, a 27-year-old woman struck and killed by an SUV driver in Manhattan in November 2022, has filed a wrongful death lawsuit. The crash occurred at Morton Street and 7th Avenue in the West Village, according to the NYPD. Schoeck was fatally hit by Gary Levinson, 62, who was driving a van the wrong way when the incident happened.

Details of the Lawsuit

Filed on Wednesday, the lawsuit claims widespread negligence by New York City, the Department of Transportation (DOT), the driver, and associated companies. Specifically, the suit states the DOT failed to install proper "One Way" and other warning signs or traffic control devices during repaving and a roadway redesign of Morton Street. Schoeck’s family alleges these missing safety measures contributed directly to the tragedy.

Allegations of Company Negligence

The lawsuit also names Courier Car Rental and Bero Parking Corp., both operating at the corner where the crash occurred. The family claims these companies were negligent for not providing adequate signage to ensure pedestrian safety. At the time of the accident, Levinson was operating a vehicle owned by Courier Car Rental, according to the lawsuit.

Statements from the Family and Legal Representation

Imran H. Ansari, attorney for the Schoeck family, issued a statement emphasizing that ordinary preventative measures by each defendant could have averted the tragedy. “Their failure to do so requires accountability and each defendant must answer to the law,” he wrote. Schoeck’s family described her as being engaged to be married and building a successful career in public relations, and conveyed their ongoing grief and commitment to seeking justice.

Driver’s Legal Outcome

Gary Levinson was arrested months after the crash and charged with criminally negligent homicide and reckless driving. In May, he pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide. His sentence included a five-year revocation of his professional license and a three-year conditional discharge, avoiding jail time but requiring compliance with court-mandated terms such as community service, which his attorney said he completed last year.

Responses from Defendants

According to the source, the city’s DOT did not immediately respond to inquiries about the lawsuit. A representative for Courier Car Rental declined to comment, and contact information for Bero Parking Corp. was not available at the time of reporting.

Scope of Damages Sought

The family’s lawsuit is seeking damages “in an amount that exceeds the jurisdictional limits of the lower Courts,” though the specific figure was not disclosed.

Ongoing Concerns over Pedestrian Safety and Legal Accountability

This case highlights ongoing concerns about pedestrian safety, traffic signage, and the responsibility of city agencies and businesses in preventing accidents arising from roadway redesign or inadequate signage.

Related coverage

Source: gothamist.com.

Recent Posts

Google Ads

add ads here

Hot Categories