
AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.
- calendar_today November 20, 2026
Amtrak Proposes Unified Rail Operations at Penn Station
Amtrak has put forward a major proposal to create a “through-running” system at Penn Station, aiming to enable direct train service between New Jersey and Long Island. Under the plan, commuters would be able to ride a single train across regional lines without needing to transfer in Manhattan, integrating services of different rail operators. However, this idea has drawn skepticism from Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) Chair Janno Lieber, who outlined his concerns during a discussion at WNYC’s The Greene Space on Tuesday.
MTA Leadership Skeptical About Construction and Disruptions
During the live interview, Lieber addressed the proposed Penn Station upgrades that would allow Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) trains to reach New Jersey and New Jersey Transit trains to continue to Long Island. Lieber argued the extensive construction required—such as removing columns and tracks to install wider platforms for faster boarding and disembarking—would result in significant disruptions for the station's 600,000 daily subway and train riders. "You can't just focus on Penn Station and start tearing apart the tracks," Lieber said. "That’s like we’re going to have to kill the village to save it."
Questions About Rail Infrastructure and Capacity
Lieber raised additional doubts regarding the logistical feasibility of "through running" at Penn Station. He noted that NJ Transit’s infrastructure and rolling stock are much older and less reliable compared to the LIRR’s. Moreover, he questioned whether there would be enough capacity in Amtrak’s East River tunnels to accommodate the increase in trains running between New Jersey and Long Island, particularly as the MTA moves forward with the Metro-North Penn Access project, which will bring Metro-North trains into Penn Station via these same tunnels.
The Broader Vision: Integration and Regional Planning
While Lieber expressed openness to "through running" as a general transportation concept for New York City’s major terminal stations, he was critical of narrowly focusing on Penn Station upgrades as proposed by Amtrak. "If you want a real through-running system, let's talk about all of the issues and do it in a systematic way," Lieber said, suggesting the need for more comprehensive regional planning and coordination. The Regional Plan Association has previously advocated for the Trans-Regional Express, a similar concept to unify MTA and NJ Transit rail operations under one agency, but Lieber said he was unenthusiastic about that vision.
Amtrak’s Studies and Future Prospects
Amtrak has been advancing Penn Station reconstruction efforts and has released studies suggesting that through running could expand service at Penn Station without the need to expand the station’s physical footprint. A follow-up Amtrak report focusing on regional train service in and out of the station is expected, likely including further exploration of through running. The idea is also linked to the pending Gateway tunnels, which are anticipated to double rail capacity between New Jersey and Midtown Manhattan. However, proposals to expand the station by demolishing blocks south of West 31st Street have faced opposition from New York Governor Kathy Hochul.
Context and Additional NYC Transit Updates
The through running debate takes place alongside a range of ongoing transit efforts in New York City. In related developments, the MTA has announced plans to upgrade subway signals across the entire system by 2050, pilot new AI camera technologies on subway trains to detect hazards, and is facing projections of significant operational budget deficits without additional financial aid. At the same WNYC event, Lieber addressed concerns about the OMNY fare payment system, promising future enhancements for better rider information at turnstiles.
Source: gothamist.com.







